« RIF ResultsTiling, Massage, "Hike," and London Arrangements »

8 comments

Comment from: Daddy [Visitor]  
Daddy

Dear One, you have begun the learning process that many have attempted to help you see. that is, that you cannot force anyone to see things as you want them to see them. Grammyh said many times ‘You can catch more flies with honey than you can with vinegar.’

You are astute, self motivated, strong willed, educated quite well indeed for a person of your level of formal education. You have a burning desire to help others tolearn, and a willingness to share yourself for that purpose. Now comes the really hrd part: Learn to lead, and to do it gently. You cannot drag a horse or a mule very far by the reins, but allow the reins to droop ever so slightly, and the animal will follow you almost anywhere. Remember though–even a mule takes time out from following to stop and eat a tasty looking tidbit, drink a bit of water, and tend to other biological needs. Your students will follow you to the end of the road if you follow the plans you have set forth above, and 1: lead, but lead gently, 2: Expect great things from each individual, and 3: Allow for mistakes, and lead them through their errors.

I like very much your ability to look at yourself, and try to improve. Need I say I am proud of you?

07/22/07 @ 21:42
Comment from: diana [Visitor]  
diana

So if you wanted to express the same ideas you just did, but avoid crushing my enthusiasm and belief in myself, how would you word it?

d

07/23/07 @ 15:23
Comment from: Andy [Visitor]  
Andy

I enjoyed very much this post. A few specific thoughts:

- Don’t just visit the classes of outstanding faculty peers. Sit in on the classes of those who aren’t as excellent (or are, in fact, just bad). This not only reminds you what NOT to do but it also does wonders for self-confidence! B)

- I’ve found that distributing handouts at the beginning of class can cause students to disregard what you say. After all, why “waste” time learning something that is explicated on a handout they already have? Instead, consider distributing handouts at the end of class and not everyday, either. Don’t let your students grow to expect receiving formal, complete handouts. Perhaps, from time to time, just distribute handouts that cover only a particular aspect of what you taught in that day’s class. :idea:

- I like the idea of giving your students leading questions to guide their reading, but I do see the concern that doing so might result in more precise reading at the expense of creative, insightful reading. Perhaps, as a compromise, distribute those questions the day before you intend to speak about them in class. In this way, students who otherwise will develop their own thoughts will have already done so and can then check that they’ve ALSO picked up what you’d like them to have picked up. :p

- Do you already have copies of the Homer texts? If not, let me know and I’ll make some suggestions for translations!

Hope your week is off to a good start!

07/23/07 @ 15:25
Comment from: [Member]

Hi, Andy. :)

Excellent points, all. A comment on the third idea: even the best students at the Academy tend to read assigned texts the night before (or the morning of) the class it’s “due.” If I give them leading questions, I do it with the understanding that I’m altering their creative reads to some degree. (At least, that’s what I expect will happen. They often surprise me, though.)

I don’t have copies of the Homer texts and haven’t yet decided which to teach. I’m quite interested in any suggestions you may have (and even more interested in the reasons behind your suggestions).

d

07/23/07 @ 17:03
Comment from: Daddy [Visitor]  
Daddy

Deeply, /deeply/ sorry I crushed you in the process. It was my stumbling way of saying I like what you are doing, I’m proud of your continued growth, and I support you all the way. I will keep my comment s to myself in the future, especially when I support your thoughts as fully as I do now, so that you will know that I think you are on the right track.

07/23/07 @ 20:18
Comment from: Hinermad [Visitor]
Hinermad

Diana,

I’m impressed that after only one year of teaching you’ve made a list of positive, actionable (yes, I hate that word too) steps to improve your skill and effectiveness as a teacher. Of course, you’ve been impressing me for years, so there’s not much surprise here.

I especially like your first point because it mirrors advice I give to parents regularly: make time for yourself. Healthy kids need healthy parents, and burying yourself in the pile of mundane tasks that grows up around kids is a sure way to sap your strength.

I’ll say it again: your students don’t know how lucky they are.

Dave

07/24/07 @ 13:27
Comment from: [Member]

Daddy,

Please accept my apologies for coming across so harshly. When I first read your response, it hurt me deeply. Over the next 24 hours, I read it a few times, expecting my perspective to change. You have the ability to make me emotionally five years old again, it seems. (Do all fathers retain this ability?)

When I read it again the next day around lunch and it still hurt, I sat and worked through several responses, most of which didn’t seem constructive. The one I settled on was intended to gently help you see that, even when we try to encourage, we can still hurt others, and may not ever know it–unless they say something. I clearly have a long way to go. That’s the problem, though…we may understand the concept for years before we find a way to apply it. The key, I think, is finding one or more good role models.

Dave,

Thanks. It’s amazing how I can KNOW that immersing myself in anything makes me less effective in the long run, but not remember to apply the knowledge. *sigh*

d

07/24/07 @ 20:09
Comment from: Aunt B'Ann [Visitor]  
Aunt B'Ann

Diana, I love your list! Wish I had done some of the things you have already done, back when I was teaching English! You are my heroine!!!

07/27/07 @ 21:03


Form is loading...